verse 1 Remember when you said you loved me? Remember when you said that it would all work out? We packed up and we left one morning And everything you promised didn't happen, and now I'm swirling softly Drifting like the cream in your coffee And you're talking calmly When I'm scared To be on our own When the thrill is gone And I'm scared Thinking what we've done To try to love someone Baby can you keep your promise? Baby can I keep you honest? Cause I'm scared (verse 2) There's nothing in the sky above me There's nothing strung below us, baby, if we fall We're caught between a spark and lightning We're caught between forever and nothing at all And I'm sorry, I love you But even those words are getting see-through And I'm losing it all to this feeling, baby I'm scared To be on our own When the thrill is gone And I'm scared Thinking what we've done To try to love someone Baby can you keep your promise? Baby can I keep you honest? Cause I'm scared (Bridge) When you say you love me When you say you love me (I'm scared) Are we ever gonna be okay? When you say you love me (I'm scared) Are we ever really gonna feel safe? When you say you love me (I'm scared) Is there something I can say? When you say you love me (I'm scared) Is it better if I walk away? When you say you love me? Cause I'm scared To be on our own And I'm scared Thinking what we've done Baby can you keep your promise? Baby can I keep you honest? Cause I'm scared